Tag Archive: Scott Sizemore

Will Rhymes, who opened the 2011 season as the Tigers starting second baseman, is now a free agent after the Tigers declined to offer him a new contract before Monday's non-tender deadline. (Brian Calloway photo)

Will Rhymes might have been short on size but was high on heart.

That is what made the 5-foot-9 and 155-pound Rhymes – a 27th round draft pick out of the College of William and Mary in 2005 – endearing to fans upon his arrival to the big leagues in 2010.

Rhymes wasn’t regarded and didn’t have the tools/skills set of a top prospect like one-time competitor at second base Scott Sizemore had, but turned in a strong showing once called up to the majors during the 2010 season. Rhymes hit .304 in 54 games with 12 doubles and three triples and won over fans with his play. That strong showing over the second half of the season helped in part earn Rhymes the first shot at second base to start the 2011.

Will Rhymes hit .306 in 104 games at Triple-A Toledo in 2011 and was a Triple-A All-Star. (B. Calloway photo)

But Rhymes never got going early in 2011 , batting .221 with 1 double in 19 games before being demoted to Triple-A Toledo and replaced on the Tigers roster by a hot-hitting Sizemore. From there, he pretty much fell out of the Tigers plans.

The 26-year old was a Triple-A All-Star in 2011, but the Tigers obviously don’t see Rhymes in the future plans which is why they declined to offer him a contract for 2012 and allowed him to become a free agent.

Even with the Tigers trading Sizemore to Oakland in May, Rhymes never found his was back to Detroit until rosters expanded in September. Instead the Tigers went with a combination of Carlos Guillen, Ryan Raburn, Ramon Santiago and Danny Worth at second base. And the Tigers appear content right now to use a platoon of Santiago and Raburn for that position in 2012.

This decision by the Tigers brass in essentially the best case scenario for both parties. With Rhymes likely being a longshot to make the major league roster out of spring training, he will get a chance to go elsewhere to try to get back to the majors. And the Tigers still have enough options at second base.


Hot start: Scott Sizemore is off to a .387 start with Toledo this season.

In five of their 16 games this season the Detroit Tigers have been held to two or fewer runs.  They are 0-5 in those games.

On eight occasions this season the team has scored three for fewer runs ans has a 2-6 record in those games. Factor in Friday’s game in which they only scored one run in the first nine innings before a huge scoring outburst in the 10th, that is nine times where the Tigers bats haven’t really done much.

Detroit ranks eighth of 14 American League teams with a .240 batting average and ninth of 14 with a .312 on-base percentage. They clearly will need to find a way to generate some offense if they hope to contend in an AL Central that has seen surprising starts from the Cleveland Indians and Kansas City Royals through the first few weeks of the season.

Getting leadoff hitter Austin Jackson going will certainly be a key to improving offensively considering the Tigers will need his defense in the spacious outfield at Comerica Park. Jackson is batting .175 with 19 strikeouts in in 16 games in his sophomore season, but his strong rookie year provided a sign that he can hit and be a strong top of the order hitter for the Tigers. Victor Martinez is also off to a slow start but he has a track record and is a former All-Star and will eventually round to form.

Which leads us to Will Rhymes, who has manned the No. 2 slot for much of the season. Rhymes is  batting .222 with no extra-base hits and has scored just two runs. While Rhymes did hit .300 in limited action in the majors last year, he has a replacement that is off to a hot start in Triple-A Toledo and the Tigers should look his way if they continue to struggle at the plate. Scott Sizemore, who battled Rhymes for the second base job this spring, is batting .387 (12 for 31) through his first nine games for the Mud Hens this season. While batting at the top of the Toledo lineup he has scored eight runs and has a pair of doubles, four RBIs, five walks and six strikeouts.

With the Tigers offense struggling, it wouldn’t hurt to call up a hot hitter like Sizemore in order to possibly provide a jump start and be a way to ignite the team. If the Tigers were hitting, it would be fine to leave Rhymes in and give him a chance to work his way out of his early season struggles. Since that isn’t the case the Tigers should opt with Sizemore to see if he can provide a spark.

The Tigers made a move with their bullpen last week with the promotion of Al Alburquerque to the bigs. Alburquerque was effective in his debut with two scoreless innings and three strikeouts during Friday’s win over the Athletics.

Detroit should in turn make a similar move with its struggling offense since there isn’t much else to lose. With its starters giving quality outings of late, its a shame a lack of offense has been the cause of several recent losses.

So long Polanco

Detroit Tigers second baseman Placido Polanco heads back to the dugout after pre-game warmups during a game in August. Polanco signed a three-year deal with the Philadelphia Phillies on Thursday. (Brian Calloway photo)

The Placido Polanco era in Detroit officially came to a halt when the Tigers decided not to offer him salary arbitration on Tuesday and with him inking a three-year with the Philadelphia Phillies today.

In my opinion, it was a smart move by the Tigers to part ways with him. With so many bad contracts (I.e. Dontrelle Willis, Nate Robertson, Magglio Ordonez, etc.) on the team, there is no way they could risk Polanco accepting arbitration or really afford to give him a three-year $18 million deal like the Phillies did. Polanco is also 34, and we’ve all seen how some others on the Tigers have started to perform now that they are approaching the end of their careers (Ordonez, Carlos Guillen).

And if the Tigers feel that Scott Sizemore is in fact ready, why not save money at that position. Especially with rumors swirling that Curtis Granderson and Edwin Jackson could be on the move to save money, having Sizemore as the second baseman makes sense instead of paying to keep Polanco.

While the Tigers had to make the move to part ways with Polanco, I’m still a little sad to see him go. He was a valuable performer for the Tigers and one of the better moves Dave Dombrowski has made during his tenure as Detroit’s general manager.

Detroit acquired Polanco in 2005 from the Phillies in a deal in which the Tigers sent relief pitcher Ugueth Urbina to Philadelphia. Polanco was strong for four-plus seasons with the Tigers and even won a Gold Glove in 2007 and 2009. He also was the MVP during the ALCS and helped the Tigers reach the World Series in 2006. He seemed to be the ultimate professional and was probably one of the best clutch hitters the Tigers had.

His .285 average this season was his worst in a full season as a Tiger and he struck out a career high 46 times this year. On the flip side he drove in a career high 72 runs this season. I will miss Polanco for what he provided the Tigers but I think its time  to see what Sizemore can offer.

From seeing Sizemore play several times this summer in Toledo, I think he can be a good offensive player. The defense remains to be seen but I think he will do all right and I hope the move pans out. Last season between stints at Double-A Erie and Triple-A Toledo, Sizemore hit .308 with 39 doubles, five triples and 17 homers and 21 stolen bases in 25 attempts. He had 95 strikeouts.

Sizemore hit .308 at Toledo in 71 games and had the 22 doubles. He was one of the Tigers delegates to the Arizona Fall League and hit .368 in six games before going down with an injury. According to a Detroit Free Press report today his fracture left ankle is getting better and he could be off crutches soon.